Matt Schouten

Thoughts on building people, software, and systems.

Warfighting Book Club – Week Three

by

in

This is Week Three in the Warfighting Book Club, relating the Marine Corps doctrinal publication Warfighting to business agility.

This section is not my favorite, but raises a lot of good questions to consider organizationally.


Warfighting Week Three Leader’s Notes and Questions

[Page numbers and quotes are taken from Warfighting, MCDP 1, 2019 Edition]

  • Sections:  Force Planning – Organization – Doctrine – Professionalism – Training – Professional Military Education – Personnel Management – Equipping – Conclusion
  • Questions:
    • If you saw this chapter’s section headings in a table of contents, with just a couple of words changed (maybe “Force” for “Team”, and either remove “Military” or focus it more on your craft), what kind of book would you think it was?
    • What is the non-military equivalent of force planning?  How often do we do that?
    • Can someone summarize the “organization” section for us?
      • We could camp out in “Organization” all day and have a great discussion, but we won’t.  But the second-to-last paragraph caught my eye.  3-5 “Operating forces should be organized for warfighting and then adapted for peacetime rather than vice versa.”
        • Let’s pause there and ask what the equivalent of “warfighting” and “peacetime” are for us.  [Project work = warfighting; training, education, learning, retros = peacetime?]
          • That has interesting implications by itself—what happens to military units that are always on a war footing?
        • What would it mean for our “operating forces” to be organized for “warfighting” (= project work)?
        • How do you react to the last sentence:  “Units should be organized according to type only to the extent dictated by training, administrative, and logistic requirements”?
    • What does “Professionalism” mean to you?
    • Do you agree with the book that “trust is an essential trait among leaders”?
    • What effect do mistakes have on your ability to trust someone else?
    • Do you err on boldness or timidity?  Does [YOUR COMPANY]?
    • READ paragraph on 3-8 “Relations among all leaders…”.  What’s your reaction to that paragraph?  How does that apply in the workplace?
    • Training is interesting to dig into:
      • How much time do we allow for OTJ training?
      • How are our training programs structured?
      • What does training typically look like for your craft?
      • In what way—and level of frankness—are critiques provided for training (or actual) events here?
    • Whose responsibility is professional development?
      • (Three-tier:  education establishment, commanders, individual Marines)
      • If you’re not growing professionally, who is responsible for that?
      • If your employees are not growing professionally, who is responsible for that?
    • What do you think of “the mind is an officer’s principal weapon”?
    • “Doctrine provides the basis for harmonious actions and mutual understanding” — do we have “Doctrine” in the workplace?
      • What is the effect of having or not having doctrine?
    • In the workplace, how much time do we spend “waging war” — doing the work — and how much do we spend “preparing for war” — learning, growing, becoming educated?
      • And what’s the effect of that ratio on our effectiveness, growth, and long-term sustainability?

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *